• Home
  • ABOUT THE SITE
  • HOW TO START CLIMBING
  • ALPS CLIMBING
    • Swiss Alps
    • Italian Alps
    • German Alps
    • Austrian Alps
    • Slovenian Alps
  • TENERIFE TOURS
    • Climbing Tours
      • Climbing Mt Teide
      • Climbing Pico Viejo Tenerife
      • From Vilaflor to Guajara
      • Guajara mountain
      • Magic Moments On Mount Teide
      • One afternoon on Teide
      • Teide mountain natural wonder
    • Hiking Tours
      • Almaciga – Benijo – Chamorga
      • Anaga Mountains Tenerife
      • Chamorga faro de Anaga
      • From Almaciga to Igueste
      • From Benijo to Roques de Anaga
      • From Chamorga to La Laguna
      • From Santa Cruz to Pico del Ingles
      • Igueste de San Andres – Playa Antequera
      • Ijuana Tenerife
      • Masca Valley Tenerife
      • Punta del Hidalgo to Santa Cruz
    • Tenerife Mountains – Hiking And Mountaineering
  • HUTS
  • ABOUT EQUIPMENT

Mountains For Everybody

Site about mountaineering, climbing and equipment, for those who love mountains

  • Outdoor Gifts Ideas
    • The Swiss Army Knife
    • Bialetti Espresso Maker
    • LifeStraw Personal Water Filter
    • Etekcity Water Filter
    • Etekcity Camping Stove
    • Casio Altimeter Barometer Thermometer Watch
  • Equipment Reviews
  • FAQs
  • Invitation for Guest Authors
  • Contact

Osprey Rook & Renn vs Osprey Exos & Eja backpacks

18/01/2019 by Jovo Leave a Comment


Here you have a comparison Osprey Rook & Renn vs Osprey Exos & Eja backpacks. These series are built to be affordable and ultra-light, so some features are missing. Read more below. 

Osprey Rook 65.
Osprey Rook 65.
Osprey Exos 58.
Osprey Exos 58.


Why this comparison

Osprey has launched a completely new series for 2019, the Rook & Renn for men and women, respectively. Those are very affordable packs, at least for such an outstanding brand. They are also lightweight packs, with a very good volume/weight ratio, but some features are missing. As usual.

On the other hand, in 2018 they have launched a new Eja series for women, which corresponds to their Exos series for men that has been around for many years already. But the Exos packs have been heavily modified and they share the same basic features as the Eja packs. Not all changes are for the better, at least from my point of view. But these packs are built to be ultra-lightweight. When they appeared on the market, I wrote a text about this and it is available here.

So, on one side you have an effort to build affordable packs, while on the other side to build exceptionally lightweight packs. The result in both cases is as expected – some features are missing. The question is where this lack of features is more substantial. The answer is below. 


A few details about Exos & Eja and Rook & Renn packs

Sizes

The Eja packs come in the following sizes Eja 38, Eja 48, and Eja 58 liters. The Exos packs are also in the sizes 38, 48, 58 liters. 

Within each of these nominal sizes, you have 3 sub-sizes. You will see this as S, M, and L sizes for men and XS, S, and M sizes in the Eja packs. So these are large series with many packs, 9 sizes in total for each of them. Now, the reason for such sizes is that the torso length is fixed in these packs, so apart from the fine-tuning with shoulder straps, you have to choose a proper sub-size within each of these nominal sizes.

But how is this in the Rook & Renn packs? Well, here you have two sizes for each of them, Rook 50 and Rook 65 liters, and also Renn 50 and Renn 65 liters. But here you have a completely adjustable shoulder harness (torso size) so there is no need for such sub-sizes.

Other basic features

I have decided to show the Renn 65 and Eja 58 packs as the representatives of the series. This will be enough to get some idea about the main features. The same basic comparison would be in the Rook vs Exos packs. 


Features

COMPARE PACKAGE FEATURES

Volume/Weight ratio, liters/kg

Adjustable torso

Access

Hip belt pockets

Rain cover

Metal frame

Bottom compartment

Pockets

Removable lid

Back panel

Price, $

Osprey
Renn 65

$99

Payable Every Month

42

yes

top, bottom

yes

yes

yes

yes

5

no

trampoline

$$

read
my review

Osprey
Eja 58 

$399

Payable Every Year

49

no

top

no

no

yes

no

5

yes

trampoline

$$$

read
my review

 

So which is better

Here is my summary:


choose your plan

Shoulder harness

Hip belt

Ventilation

Weight

Pockets

Attachment elements

Access

Organization

Carry load

Fabric

My verdict

Rook & Renn

$10

per month

8/10 Better

Exos & Eja

$30

per month

4/10 

 

You might want to know my reasons and explanation for the rating in the table, so here they are:

Regarding the shoulder harness: The Rook & Renn series have a fully adjustable shoulder harness and this includes the following:

  • Adjustable torso length. 
  • Two different attachment positions for the load lifters.

None of these is available in the Exos & Eja series, hence my rating. Also, you have a full padding on the Rook & Renn packs while the Exos & Eja have a very thin but really cool looking padding on the shoulder straps. 

Hip belt: The Rook & Renn are with a fully padded hip belt and this is not so in the Exos & Eja packs where you have only very short flaps on the hip bones with just a bit of thin padding. In my view this is where Rook & Renn beat them totally. To understand what I mean, please see the hip belt in the Exos and Eja packs:

The new Exos hip belt padding and lumbar zone.
The new Exos hip belt padding and lumbar zone.

Now see how this is with the hip belt in the Renn 50 pack, this is beyond comparison:

The hip belt in the Osprey Renn 50 pack.
The hip belt in the Osprey Renn 50 pack.

Ventilation: This is excellent in both series, and I am pretty sure there is nothing better on the market. It is completely on the level of Deuter Futura Vario packs.

Why am I mentioning Deuter here? The reason is simple, Deuter has invented this tensioned mesh system and introduced in their Futura series several decades ago. I  have been carrying their packs with such a design in the past 20 years. Nowadays more and more brands are switching to this concept, and this is with all good reasons.

Weight: Obviously, Exos & Eja packs are ultra-lightweight so they are clear winners here.

Pockets: This is interesting to compare. Both series have the same number, but they are differently organized. See what I mean:

  • In the Rook & Renn you have 2 hip belt pockets, 2 side pockets, and 1 lid pocket.
  • In the Exos & Eja there are no hip belt pockets (there is no place on those minimal hip flaps), but you have 2 side pockets, 2 lid pockets, and 1 front pocket. Note that the front stretch pocket here is gigantic so this is a very useful space.

Now, this is the matter of preference, it depends which combination you find more useful. I give them the same rating here, but the Exos & Eja offer more with their pockets.

One addition: the Rook & Renn packs have one extra pocket on the bottom where the rain cover comes, but you can use it as you wish.

Attachment elements: I shall not list here what the same is in both series, I shall focus on the differences only.

  • So in the Exos & Eja you have Osprey’s famous Stow-on-the-Go attachment for poles, and this is missing in the Rook & Renn. 
  • In the Exos & Eja you have a loop for the ice axe, paired with a bungee tie-off higher on the pack. This is missing in the Rook & Renn.
  • There are more webbing loops on the Exos & Eja packs.

Access: You can access the Rook & Renn from the top and from the bottom. Only top access is in the Exos & Eja packs.

Organization: Here I mean mainly the bottom compartment and the mentioned extra access in the Rook & Renn packs. This is missing in the Exos & Eja packs. 

Carry load: I have no doubt that from this point of view the Rook & Renn packs are far better, they come with a fully padded hip belt. The hip belt in the Exos & Eja packs is almost without any padding and the same is on the shoulder straps.

Fabric: You have 600D polyester in the Rook & Renn, while in the Exos & Eja you have 100D high tenacity nylon triple check dobby, and the bottom is 210D high tenacity nylon.

Extras: The rain cover in the Rook & Renn adds value. The rain cover is important for me, would not go without it in the area where I do my mountaineering tours. 


Final thoughts

So this was my comparison Osprey Rook & Renn vs Osprey Exos & Eja backpacks, I have presented some basic facts and how I see these four series. There is no doubt that Rook and Renn are better backpacks. They are lightweight and some features are missing but nothing is sacrificed in their suspension.

The suspension is essential, the main purpose of a backpack is to carry the weight. In the case of Exos packs, the hip belt in the previous version was far better, although they have introduced a great ventilation panel in the new version.

What do you think? Do share your opinion, there is a comment box below.


Filed Under: Backpacks, Mountain climbing equipment Tagged With: Osprey Rook & Renn series

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Choose the language

en English
en Englishja Japanesede Germanfr Frenchzh-CN Chinese (Simplified)ru Russianes Spanishnl Dutchko Koreanpt Portugueseit Italiansv Swedishno Norwegiansr Serbianpl Polishfi Finnishiw Hebrewda Danishcs Czechaf Afrikaanssq Albanianam Amharicar Arabichy Armenianaz Azerbaijanieu Basquebe Belarusianbn Bengalibs Bosnianbg Bulgarianca Catalanceb Cebuanony Chichewazh-TW Chinese (Traditional)co Corsicanhr Croatianeo Esperantoet Estoniantl Filipinofy Frisiangl Galicianka Georgianel Greekgu Gujaratiht Haitian Creoleha Hausahaw Hawaiianhi Hindihmn Hmonghu Hungarianis Icelandicig Igboid Indonesianga Irishjw Javanesekn Kannadakk Kazakhkm Khmerku Kurdish (Kurmanji)ky Kyrgyzlo Laola Latinlv Latvianlt Lithuanianlb Luxembourgishmk Macedonianmg Malagasyms Malayml Malayalammt Maltesemi Maorimr Marathimn Mongolianmy Myanmar (Burmese)ne Nepalips Pashtofa Persianpa Punjabiro Romaniansm Samoangd Scottish Gaelicst Sesothosn Shonasd Sindhisi Sinhalask Slovaksl Slovenianso Somalisu Sudanesesw Swahilitg Tajikta Tamilte Teluguth Thaitr Turkishuk Ukrainianur Urduuz Uzbekvi Vietnamesecy Welshxh Xhosayi Yiddishyo Yorubazu Zulu

My photo.Hi everybody and welcome to my site which I nurture with love and passion. Here I describe my own climbs and give reviews of equipment. I hope you will enjoy it. More about the site and about me here.


Categories


Cookies Statement

In this site we do not have any cookie tool. But we do use services by third parties that either use cookies or may be doing so, yet we do not have any control of it. This is covered in their privacy policies. For more details please check in our Privacy Policy page.


  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Affiliate Disclosure

My Most Memorable Tours

  • Magic Moments On Mount Teide Tenerife
  • Climbing Weissmies solo
  • Climbing Mount Fuji
  • Climbing Zugspitze solo
  • Lagginhorn my first 4000er

Recent Posts

What is Wrong with Deuter

What is Wrong with Deuter – Question Did Not Meet Guidelines

Exped Mira II HL Tent

Exped Mira II HL Tent – Top Quality & Lightweight

Exped SynMat 9 pad

Exped SynMat 9 Review – Insulated Inflatable Sleeping Pad

Deuter Futura 30 Review

Deuter Futura 30 Review – Excellent Ventilation

Big Agnes Bolten SL 20 Degree Sleeping Bag

Big Agnes Bolten SL 20 Degree Sleeping Bag – Stretchy & PrimaLoft

Affiliate Disclosure

I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com. So when you buy something from this website, I may receive an affiliate commission. These are my opinions and are not representative of the companies that create these products. My reviews are based on my personal experience and research. I never recommend poor quality products, or create false reviews to make sales. It is my intention to explain products so you can make an informed decisions on which ones suit your needs best.

Categories

  • About mountains in general (21)
  • Austrian Alps (5)
  • FAQs (28)
  • freeze dried food (1)
  • German Alps (3)
  • Great mountain roads and passes (6)
  • Guest Author posts (1)
  • Hiking tours (11)
  • Huts and Shelters (8)
  • Italian Alps (20)
  • Mountain climbing equipment (678)
    • Backpacks (285)
    • Boots & shoes (34)
    • Camp stuff (16)
    • Clothing (64)
    • Gadgets (1)
    • Helmets & headlamps (22)
    • Sleeping bags and pads (65)
    • Tents and shelters (147)
    • Trekking poles (13)
    • Water filters & purifiers (22)
  • Slovenian Alps (11)
  • Swiss Alps (19)
  • Tenerife (19)
  • Uncategorized (4)

Copyright © 2019 · Metro Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in